BACKGROUND: About 8,800-34,200 Gender Dysphoria (GD)- and 39,000-650,800 Mayer-Rokitansky-Küster-Hauser (MRKH)-patients undergo vaginoplasty annually. Various procedures are available, but comparisons are lacking. OBJECTIVES: To highlight information gaps, weaknesses and strengths of vaginoplasty techniques, to aid well-informed decision making by patients and healthcare professionals. SEARCH STRATEGY: A systematic search in Medline, EMBASE, Web of Science and Scopus until October 6, 2022, by PICO method and PROSPERO registration. SELECTION CRITERIA: Original retrospective studies on complete neovaginal creation in adult GD- and MRKH-patients and discussing anatomy, Quality of Life (QoL), satisfaction, sexual function, complications or complaints. DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS: The 95% confidence intervals were calculated with DerSimonian and Laird random-effects. Methodological quality and potential bias were assessed. MAIN RESULTS: In total, 35 GD- and 16 MRKH-studies were eligible. Vagina length was 11.6 and 9.5 cm, respectively. In GD-patients, Hemorrhage (6%), prolapse (1%), gastrointestinal complications (1%), revisions (26%), pain (6%), regret (1%), fecal- (11%) and urinary issues (17%) were reported. Necrosis, stenosis, dyspareunia and revisions decreased, while duration increased with higher graft quantity. Intestinal-vaginoplasty reported 100% sensation. MRKH-patients reported more necrosis (17%) [McIndoe] and average satisfaction with sexual function (91%) and vaginal discharge (32%). They were more sexually active (86%) and had 100% anatomical satisfaction. Only Intestinal-vaginoplasty reported overall dissatisfaction. CONCLUSIONS: For GD- and MRKH-patients, multiple safe vaginoplasty techniques demonstrated acceptable outcomes, with significantly improved QoL and self-image. However, standardized validation tools are needed for well-informed decision-making. Direct technique comparisons per patient-cohort and exploration of tissue-engineering methods are critical for future surgical advancements.

BACKGROUND: About 430,000-1,000,000 Gender Dysphoria- and Mayer-Rokitanksy-Küster-Hauser-patients undergo vaginoplasty each year. Various surgical procedures are available, but direct comparisons are lacking. This inhibits well-informed decision making by patients and healthcare professionals. OBJECTIVES: Highlight information gaps, weaknesses and strengths of todays vaginoplasty techniques. SEARCH STRATEGY: A systematic search in Medline, EMBASE, Web of Science and Scopus until March 8, 2022 was conducted, by PICO method and PROSPERO registration. SELECTION CRITERIA: Original retrospective studies on complete neovaginal creation in adult Gender Dysphoria- and Mayer-Rokitanksy-Küster-Hauser-patients and discussing anatomical outcome, Quality of Life, satisfaction, sexual function, complications and/or complaints. DATA COLLECTION AND ANALYSIS: Data was extracted and methodological quality and potential bias were assessed. The 95% confidence intervals were calculated with DerSimonian and Laird random-effects. MAIN RESULTS: A total of 47 articles were eligible. Surgery took 198 minutes with 10.2 cm vaginal length. Major complications included 5% hemorrhage, 1% gastrointestinal complications, 1% prolapse, 3% tissue necrosis and 6% stenosis, with 31% revisions. Patients reported 25% excessive discharge, 6% pain, 11% fecal- and 17% urinary issues and one case of hair growth. Patients also reported 95% aesthetic- and 93% anatomical satisfaction, 10% overall dissatisfaction and 1% regret. Reports showed 75% sexual activity, 13% dyspareunia, 87% sensation and 84% overall functional satisfaction. CONCLUSIONS: Multiple vaginoplasty techniques demonstrated safe and acceptable outcomes, with significant improvement of Quality of Life and self-image. However, standardized validation tools are needed for well-informed decision-making. Direct technique comparisons with similar cohorts and exploration of tissue-engineering methods are critical for future surgical advancements.