Climate change is affecting ocean temperature, acidity, currents, and primary production, causing shifts in species distributions, marine ecosystems, and ultimately fisheries. Earth system models simulate climate change impacts on physical and biogeochemical properties of future oceans under varying emissions scenarios. Coupling these simulations with an ensemble of global marine ecosystem models indicates decreasing global fish biomass with warming. However, regional projections of these impacts remain much more uncertain. Here, we employ CMIP5 and CMIP6 climate change impact projections using two Earth system models coupled with four regional and nine global marine ecosystem models in ten ocean regions to evaluate model agreement at regional scales. We find that models developed at different scales can lead to stark differences in biomass projections. On average, global models projected greater biomass declines by the end of the 21st century than regional models. For both global and regional models, greater biomass declines were projected using CMIP6 than CMIP5 simulations. Global models projected biomass declines in 86% of CMIP5 simulations for ocean regions compared to 50% for regional models in the same ocean regions. In CMIP6 simulations, all global model simulations projected biomass declines in ocean regions by 2100, while regional models projected biomass declines in 67% of the ocean region simulations. Our analysis suggests that improved understanding of the causes of differences between global and regional marine ecosystem model climate change projections is needed, alongside observational evaluation of modelled responses.

We use inverse modelling to infer the distribution and drivers of community-integrated zooplankton grazing dynamics based on the skill with which different grazing formulations recreate the satellite-observed seasonal cycle in phytoplankton biomass. We find that oligotrophic and eutrophic biomes require more and less efficient grazing dynamics, respectively. This is characteristic of micro- and mesozooplankton, respectively, and leads to a strong sigmoidal relationship between observed mean-annual phytoplankton biomass and the optimal grazing parameterization required to simulate its seasonal cycle. Globally, we find Type III rather than Type II functional response curves consistently exhibit higher skill. These new observationally-based distributions can help constrain, validate and develop next-generation biogeochemical models.

We examine how zooplankton influence phytoplankton bloom phenology from the top-down, then use inverse modelling to infer the distribution and drivers of mean community zooplankton grazing dynamics based on the skill with which different simulated grazing formulations are able to recreate the observed seasonal cycle in phytoplankton biomass. We find that oligotrophic (eutrophic) biomes require more (less) efficient grazing dynamics, characteristic of micro- (meso-) zooplankton, leading to a strong relationship between the observed mean annual phytoplankton concentration in a region and the optimal grazing parameterization required to simulate it’s observed phenology. Across the globe, we found that a type III functional response consistently exhibits more skill than a type II response, suggesting the mean dynamics of a coarse model grid-cell should offer stability and prey refuge at low biomass concentrations. These new observationally-based global distributions will be invaluable to help constrain, validate and develop next generation of biogeochemical models.

For nearly a century, the functional response curves, which describe how predation rates vary with prey density, have been a mainstay of ecological modelling. While originally derived to describe terrestrial interactions, they have been adopted to characterize aquatic systems in marine biogeochemical, size-spectrum, and population models. However, marine ecological modellers disagree over the qualitative shape of the curve (e.g. Type II vs. III), whether its parameters should be mechanistically or empirically defined (e.g. disk vs. Michaelis-Menten scheme), and the most representative value of those parameters. As a case study, we focus on marine biogeochemical models, providing a comprehensive theoretical, empirical, and numerical road-map for interpreting, formulating, and parameterizing the functional response when used to prescribe zooplankton specific grazing rates on a single prey source. After providing a detailed derivation of each of the canonical functional response types explicitly for aquatic systems, we review the literature describing their parameterization. Empirical estimates of each parameter vary by over three orders of magnitude across 10 orders of magnitude in zooplankton size. However, the strength and direction of the allometric relationship between each parameter and size differs depending on the range of sizes being considered. In models, which must represent the mean state of different functional groups, size spectra or in many cases the entire ocean’s zooplankton population, the range of parameter values is smaller, but still varies by two to three orders of magnitude. Next, we conduct a suite of 0-D NPZ simulations to isolate the sensitivity of phytoplankton population size and stability to the grazing formulation. We find that the disk parameterizations scheme is much less sensitive to it parameterization than the Michaelis-Menten scheme, and quantify the range of parameters over which the Type II response, long known to have destabilizing properties, introduces dynamic instabilities. Finally, we use a simple theoretical model to show how the mean apparent functional response, averaged across sufficient sub-grid scale heterogeneity diverges from the local response. Collectively, we recommend using a type II disk response for models with smaller scales and finer resolutions but suggest that a type III Michaelis-Menten response may do a better job of capturing the complexity of all processes being averaged across in larger scale and coarser resolution modal, not just local consumption and capture rates. While we focus specifically on the grazing formulation in marine biogeochemical models, we believe these recommendations are robust across a much broader range of ecosystem models.

Although zooplankton play a substantial role in the biological carbon pump and serve as a crucial link between primary producers and higher trophic level consumers, the skillful representation of zooplankton is not often a focus of ocean biogeochemical models. Systematic evaluations of zooplankton in models could improve their representation, but so far, ocean biogeochemical skill assessment of Earth system model (ESM) ensembles have not included zooplankton. Here we use a recently developed global, observationally-based map of mesozooplankton biomass to assess the skill of mesozooplankton in six CMIP6 ESMs. We also employ a biome-based assessment of the ability of these models to reproduce the observed relationship between mesozooplankton biomass and surface chlorophyll. The combined analysis found that most models were able to reasonably simulate the large regional variations in mesozooplankton biomass at the global scale. Additionally, three of the ESMs simulated a mesozooplankton-chlorophyll relationship within the observational bounds, which we used as an emergent constraint on future mesozooplankton projections. We highlight where differences in model structure and parameters may give rise to varied mesozooplankton distributions under historic and future conditions, and the resultant wide ensemble spread in projected changes in mesozooplankton biomass. Despite differences, the strength of the mesozooplankton-chlorophyll relationships across all models was related to the projected changes in mesozooplankton biomass globally and in regional biomes. These results suggest that improved observations of mesozooplankton and their relationship to chlorophyll will better constrain projections of climate change impacts on these important animals.

Macroecological relationships provide insights into rules that govern ecological systems. Bergmann’s Rule posits that members of the same clade are larger at colder temperatures. Whether temperature drives this relationship is debated because several other potential drivers covary with temperature. We conducted a near-global comparative analysis on marine copepods (100,326 samples, 388 taxa) to test Bergmann’s Rule, considering other potential drivers. Supporting Bergmann’s Rule, we found temperature better predicted size than did latitude or oxygen, with body size decreasing by 44.7% across the temperature range (-1.7–30ºC). Body size also decreased by 46.0% across the range in food availability and increased by 11.3% across high-predation to low-predation systems. Our results provide strong support for Bergman’s Rule in copepods, but emphasises the importance of other drivers in modifying this pattern. As the world warms, smaller copepod species are likely to emerge as “winners”, potentially reducing rates of fisheries production and carbon sequestration.