Data, Code, and Materials Transparency
Are the following present and sufficient to independently reproduce all claimed results?
For reused public datasets:
  1. data URIs, program code, statistics scripts
For new data and resources
  1. New data available at a trusted digital repository OR all available in paper
  2. Variables, parameters, treatment conditions, and observation (number)
  3. Full procedures for collection, preprocessing, cleaning, or generating the data
  4. Code, scripts, codebooks, algorithms (URI or all in paper)
  5. Research materials (description and source) and procedures necessary to conduct an independent replication of the research.
Exceptions for ethical or legal restrictions to reproducible research
  1. Conditions on the dataset or materials that restrict researcher access and use
  2. Access protocol for data or materials
  3. Access to software and other documentation
  4. Indicate all data and materials without the above constraints
Resources available at a community-endorsed public repository
  1. Authors request delay of access until publication
  2. Do the editors identify any factors that might delay peer review/ delay acceptance for publication/ require editorial explanation upon publication /need expression of editorial concern / risk author might need to retract because of reproducibility concerns?